I appreciate you sitting with this and not just chopping it down. It’s a relatively new idea to me that I want to see how long it holds.
I think we are making the same point about the term “truth exists” as part of a meaningful statement.
I am saying meaningful statements tell us “X exists truly”, which tell us the same thing as “I know X.” If referencing knowing qua knowing, it is equivalent to say “I know X” and “I know X truly” because we don’t have knowledge without a true unification of knowing and being in the first place. Like it is superfluous to say “X exists” but add “X exists truly” because if X didn’t exist truly in the first place, we couldn’t have said “X exists”. And it is impossible to say “I know the truth” without simultaneously saying “I know what exists”.
These being-knowing-truth nodes are all tied up in each other. We humans get to (or are forced to, depending on how your day is going) move among them, as the knowing node, and with all three as we are self-aware of the act of knowing.
And we need the third truth node otherwise there couldn’t be a motion from disconnected existing things and knowers to connected up knowledge of the truth of being (or true knowledge of what is, or just knowing, back to the grammatical redundancies…). Truth is the bridge overlapping what is with what we know.
I like what you bring up here.
I agree. Quantifying over truth is what I meant by making “truth” a “being”. I am saying being-knowing-truth is a three-node mechanism, that, so far, doesn’t seem capable of uncoupling (un-tripling I guess). So if we quantify truth like it is being, we make a truth-knowing-truth triad, or really just break the whole function of the truth node into meaninglessness (at least on the first side of the truth-knowing-truth mess I’ve just made).
But I think it is clarifying to think of being-knowing-truth as a similar mechanism to “quantifying” itself. When we quantify, we say “there is one thing” and “I know it.” We’ve just invoked our knowing and the truth of it all simultaneously. Our ability to quantify at all, is the same ability to link our knowledge to being, and if the quantity holds strong as we link our knowledge to being, we have truly quantified, we possess the truth of the being that we know, etc., etc.
This is all how it plays out on paper, in ideal TPF world. This all has to be developed and tested to account for errors in knowledge, illusions in being, lies, etc.. But I can’t seem to make a move without dragging being, knowing and truth with me at every steps, which is back to the simple point I’m making (which has to agree with you that “let’s just not quantify over truth.”)
In the end though, the whole thing falls apart without each other, so it remains tempting to try to inquire about the existence of beings, the existence of knowledge and the existence of truth.
Truth does in some sense exist - we need three nodes. But here is where I think I am bumping into the impossibilities of language, because “X exists” always linguistically implies “X” is a thing, a being, and that is not how truth subsists, persists, shines, exhales (I give up..).
Yes, and no. First, no, because the point is, we have to invoke being-knowing-truth in order to understand anything, so if we are trying to understand being-knowing-truth, or just being, or just knowing, or just truth, we are chasing our own tail as if we didn’t think we could chase anything, while we are chasing…our own tail… Also, no, because we are trying to clarify what ‘is’ is - and the grammar just gets absurd.
In a way, I probably have to say less to clarify “being” or “truth”.
But if we can just sit with the absurdity, and not let the grammar distract us, ontological being is the unspoken thing, thereness, it, that which grabs the attention of our intention. In this sense, I personally define being as ‘becoming’ - living, ex-isting. I have no concern for how these sentences read, but only the ‘ing’ of reading - that is the ontology referenced by “being” in the being-knowing-truth idea.
All along I have been referencing three nodes - but even that division is confusing the ontology of this for sake of grammatical, linear grasping through sentences. Three nodes of being-knowing-truth misconstrues that this is really one unified occurrence. Me knowing what is, is a living unity, held together in me with the thing known. Removing one node, diffuses the others in the exact some moment. The grammatical “there is” doesn’t work that way. I can easily and meaningfully say ‘There is being’, ‘there is knowing being’, and ‘there is true or false knowing of being’. I can remove a couple things here and linguistically preserve the others, quantifying conceptual versions. But that isn’t how the being-knowing-truth mechanism functions. If I remove the being from being-knowing-truth, I know nothing truly. If I remove the knowing, true being is no longer there for anyone. If I remove the truth, should I still call it being, or knowing? They invoke and conjure up each other at once.