It is! I continue to be interested in informal logic and other forms of credulity that are less philosophical for this reason.
As you said, and explained prior:
“Credulity”, or in loftier language, “Inference to the Best Explanation” is something I’ve frequently pondered. It’s clearly not deductive, and so invalid in the way you’ve used that term.
The deflection in that thread was an appeal to informal logic, but this is getting off topic from this thread.
Sorry @JosephHugh for the divergence.
Straightforwardly to your question:
I agree with your position as an agnostic atheist.
A term of art I picked up from the previous forum is “apatheist”, which I like only when pressed or thinking about philosophy and such. It means “I don’t care that God exists, or that he does not exist – I will live my life in the manner as I see fit”