Here, I would like to discuss the existence of the Creator and the Sustainer based on the fact that physical substance has pure potentiality. First, I have to show that nothing cannot turn into something. I discussed this in another thread in the archive here. The original argument in that thread was the subject of extensive discussion and revision, and we eventually managed to finalize two versions of the argument; one of them is mine, and another is from Bob Ross. Here you can find my argument and his argument in order.
My version:
P1) Time is needed for change
P2) There is no time in nothing
C1) Therefore, change in nothing is not possible (from P1 and P2)
P3) Nothing to something needs a change in nothing
C2) Therefore, nothing to something is not possible (from P3 and C1)
Bob Ross version:
P1) If an entity is the pure negation of all possible existence, then it cannot be subjected to temporality
P2) ‘Nothing’ is the pure negation of all possible existence
C1) Therefore, ‘nothing’ cannot be subjected to temporality
P3) Change requires temporality
P4) ‘Nothing’ cannot be subjected to temporality
C2) Therefore, ‘nothing’ cannot be subjected to change
P5) ‘Nothing’ becoming ‘something’ requires change
P6) ‘Nothing’ cannot be subjected to change
C3) Therefore, ‘nothing’ cannot be subjected to becoming (something)
So there was something instead of nothing. Now that we established that something existed, we have to investigate things further. There are four types of existence: Pure actual, actual, potential, and pure potential. We say that something is purely actual if it exists and has a set of definite properties and it cannot undergo substantial change (it cannot turn into other things, cannot be created and destroyed). We say that something is actual if it exists and has a set of definite properties but can undergo a substantial change. An electron is an example of such a thing since it has definite properties, but it can undergo substantial change (it can turn into a neutrino and a photon). We say something is potential if it exists, does not have a set of definite properties, and cannot undergo substantial change. A string is an example of such a thing, since it exists, does not have a set of definite properties, and cannot undergo substantial change. Finally, we say that something is purely potential if it exists, does not have a set of definite properties, and can undergo substantial change. Branes are an example of such a thing in M-theory.
Physical substance cannot be purely actual. This is discussed in another thread, which you can find here. Physical substance cannot be actual as well because of the explanatory gap in defining the physical properties of physical substance and forces. Physical substance cannot be potential as well, as theories such as string theory cannot reproduce proper experimental results. Moreover, there are different string theories. M-theory encompasses all string theories. So physical substance is pure potential.
Here I first argue in favor of the Sustainer, considering that physical substance is pure potential.
P1) Pure potential things can be destroyed and created
P2) There is at least one possible state of affairs in which pure potential things do not exist
C1) Pure potential things can fail to exist (from P1 and P2)
P3) Physical substance has pure potentiality
C2) Therefore, physical substance can fail to exist (from C1 and P3)
P4) Physical substance exists persistently
P5) If something can fail to exist on its own and nevertheless exists, then there must be something else on which its existence depends
C3) Therefore, there is a Sustainer that sustains physical substance (from C2, P4, and P5)
P6) A sustaining explanation possessing potentiality would itself require a sustaining explanation
P7) An infinite regress of sustaining explanations is impossible
C4) Therefore, the Sustainer is pure actuality (from C3, P6, and P7)
Now that we have established the existence of a sustainer, I would like to argue for a Creator.
P1) Physical substance is sustained temporarily
P2) The act of sustaining cannot go back into the eternal past
C1) Therefore, there was a point at which physical substance did not exist (from P1 and P2)
P3) Physical substance has pure potentiality
P4) Whatever can be created cannot bring itself into existence
C2) Therefore, physical substance cannot be the cause of itself (from P3 and P4)
P5) Physical substance exists
P6) Whatever begins to exist and cannot cause itself must be caused by something else
C3) Therefore, there was a point at which physical substance was brought into existence (from C1, C2, P5, and P6)
P7) The act of bringing something into existence is the act of creation
C4) Therefore, there is a Creator of physical substance (from C3 and P6)
P8) A creator explanation possessing potentiality would itself require another creator
P9) An infinite regress of creator explanation is impossible
C5) Therefore, the Creator is pure actuality (from C4, P8, and P9)