I’m not surprised, but I am also not constrained by Schopenhauer’s views. He was admirably a student of biology, but he didn’t have Darwin. Even Darwin didn’t know that a single sperm cell can fertilize an egg. In many ways, Dawkins gives us a concentrated and demystified Schopenhauer in The Selfish Gene. Of course Dawkins is generally weak as a philosopher, but in this particular book he “grounds” the essential (distinctive) claims of Schopenhauer in empirical science, illuminated by mathematics.
I’m curious whether you find it plausible that other cultural animals may be “out there” beyond our solar system ? Personally, I don’t see why not. I usually only think about it in the context of philosophy, but Kant thought about it in his anthropology. Why does “the rational animal” have 5 fingers on each of its 2 hands ? Why 2 eyes rather than 8 ?
Feuerbach saw that God’s “lack of a body” contributed to God serving as a projection of the essence of our species. This essence — here we largely agree — is “reason.”
But are we the only species with “reason” ? If it is this “reason” that lifts us above the other animals, then it’s not clear that it matters that we have 5 fingers on each hand and two eyes connected to each brain.
Just as the Divine Being is nothing other than the being of man freed from the limits of nature, so is the essence of absolute idealism nothing other than the essence of subjective idealism freed from the limits, and, indeed, rational limits of subjectivity, that is, from sensuousness or objectivity as such.
Taken as an intelligible (geistig) or an abstract being, that is, regarded neither as human nor as sensuous, but rather as one that is an object for and accessible only to reason or intelligence, God qua God is nothing but the essence of reason itself. But, basing themselves rather on imagination, ordinary theology and Theism regard him as an independent being existing separately from reason. Under these circumstances, it is an inner, a sacred necessity that the essence of reason as distinguished from reason itself be at last identified with it and the divine being thus be apprehended, realised, as the essence of reason. It is on this necessity that the great historical significance of speculative philosophy rests. The proof of the proposition that the divine essence is the essence of reason or intelligence lies in the fact that the determinations or qualities of God, in so far as they are rational or intelligible and not determinations of sensuousness or imagination, are, in fact, qualities of reason.
“God is unconditional, general – ‘God is not this or that particular thing’ – immutable, eternal, or timeless being.” But absoluteness, immutability, eternality, and generality are, according to the judgment of metaphysical theology itself, also qualities of the truths or laws of reason, and hence the qualities of reason itself; for what else are these immutable, general, absolute, and universally valid truths of reason if not expressions of the essence of reason itself?
“God is the independent, autonomous being not requiring any other being in order to exist, hence subsisting entirely by and through itself.” But even this abstract, metaphysical characterisation has meaning and reality only as a definition of the essence of intelligence and, as such, it states only that God is a thinking and intelligent being or, vice versa, that the thinking being is the divine being; for only a sensuous being will need some other being outside itself in order to exist.
FWIW, I think that “God” is “the great thought” of the human species, for this thought of “God” is part of the swelling self-consciousness of our species. Human reason is essentially “trans-human” in the sense that it is not essentially tied to the DNA that we share. The lady from Neptune with sonar enjoys reading Plato. And the humans of 2450 enjoy ancient spiritual works perhaps from distant solar systems.
One might say: but perhaps we alone in the vast universe have “reason.” I can at least grant that I may well die without having seen any evidence to the contrary. But I think it would be difficult to make a conclusive case for our species as the only “reasonable” one in the universe. Of course this was the traditional view, and Galileo was famously punished for threatening the dominance of this view.