No, I’m not. If we can’t break out of such a scenario, or even see it for what it is despite not being able to break out, then all we know is how things are presented to us. A rock that presents itself to us as primary particles, atoms, and molecules, and the ways we can interact with the rock, are the same whether the information about it enters our brains through our sense organs, or is fed directly into our disembodied brains in vats.
Concerning RQM, and mostly concerning the wiki quotes:
It seems very wrong to use ‘observer’ in that way here. RQM does not give any special treatment to observers. There is simply two systems, the one measuring (being entangled with the state of) the other.
It is inspired by the key idea behind special relativity, that the details of an observation depend on the reference frame of the observer
Again, not so much the reference frame, but the event of the measurement (any system at a time and place), and events are invariant, i.e. not frame dependent.
Not so sure I like this RQM wiki. It seems misleading.
The essential idea behind RQM is that different observers may give different accurate accounts of the same system.
Yes, RQM says that, but it’s something true of pretty much any interpretation that doesn’t hold to the principle of counterfactual definiteness (PoCD). So it’s hardly a revolutionary statement.
So if B measures A, then A is said to exist in relation to B. Existence (ontology) is a relation under RQM, and treating it thus solves the whole ‘why is there something?’ query, which reduces to ‘why does something relate to me?’.
I still protest the term ‘perception’ since perception implies epistemology, and RQM is not an epistemic interpretation. Anyway, granting those terms, I’d say an object is just one perception of it. One does not perceive multiple states (superpositions).
The god eye view typically is objective, pretty incompatible with RQM which requires a system event with which to relate.
MWI (the entire universal wave function) would qualify more as something that could be objectively considered like that.
This means that there is no “true” object or “true” state of the object.
Just so, yes.
You are setting a linguistic trap by conflating “reality” with “perception of reality.”
Asking if objective reality requires a “God’s POV” is a category error. A “point of view” requires a biological organism with sensory organs processing data. The physical universe does not have a point of view. It does not look at itself. It is a Brute Fact, because it is necissary.
And the idea that we need “God’s eyes” whatever that means, in order to perceive objective reality is just not true. You do not need to be a god to know that you are clearly attempting to engage in a rational conversation with other thinking agents in the one rality in which we all both share. So you have already accepted axiomatically that objective reality exists and you (I assume) are not a god.
And if you have not accepted this, then what exactly are you trying to do here? Who are you talking to? And in which reality?
I open by saying that I think we both have the same attitude. I consider myself a positivist, but informed by thinkers like Bakhtin. Old-fashioned logical positivism was still too unwittingly theological about language.
We very much agree that my speech enacts the belief that I share an empirical world with others.
The empirical world is trivially the experienced world and therefore “subjective” in the sense of:
But this means that the physical world does look at itself. If “physical” is not a “ghost story word,” then the physical is fundamentally experiential and “from-animal-POV.”
So your approach is insufficiently positivistic and empirical for my taste.
I, for instance, would never “explain” “consciousness.” Or the Tooth Fairy. Because I reject the ghost story of consciousness-as-inside-stuff altogether.
Consciousness does not exist. The world exists. Things exist.
To me you are speaking from “within” the ghost story here. Just as a theologian promises me a God that I can’t experience, a certain kind of theological materialism “hides” the pseudo-theo-physical “behind” experience-as-skull-ghost.
Are you going to tell me next that experience is “magical ghost stuff” in the brain ? You tell me I conflate perception and things in the common world, so I don’t know. But if so, I turn your own point against you.
Precisely.
More concretely: if I tell Joe across the table that “the coffee is great here” then I am talking about the experienced-qualitative coffee and not some “ectoplasmic qualia gunk” in my “pineal gland.”
I immediately share empirical reality with others. Consciousness does not exist — is a ghost story. But this ghost story was motivated by the “from-a-point-of-view-ness” of empirical reality. The giant mistake in post-Christian philosophy was to interpret this “from-a-point-of-view-ness” as “inside-mind-stuff-ness.”
“Objective reality” in the sense of “reality beyond all possible experience” functioning as “truth maker” is part of the ghost story.
What? Reality that is beyond experience is a “ghost story”? If there is no objective reality “beyond” our experience, what the hell was the universe doing for about 13.7 billion years before sensory organs evolved and experienced it? There was no reality here? There were no planets? No stars? And those stars that have a light cone shining toward Earth don’t exist? I don’t know who told you this is “positivism.” This is radical idealism. It the height of anthropocentric conceit.
Yeah, consciousness is not a physical thing. It is not (a noun, a ghost, some kind of magic substance). It’s a process. Like food digestion. It’s a biological process (a verb). If you are even saying the process doesn’t exist, you might as well say “digestion doesn’t exist, only food and stomachs exist.” That doesn’t have anything do with getting rid of “ghosts”, that is just denying basic biology.
Ok, yeah. If you’re are talking about the biological interface, if you mean the chemical reaction between the liquid and your taste receptors, sure. But then if you catch COVID tomorrow and you can’t taste anything, the physical, molecular composition of the coffee in that mug changes? I am not sure the objective reality of coffee would change just because you can’t taste it anymore. The physical place does not care about what your map says, or even if your map is there. The planets are still there; your coffee is still there, whether you can taste it or not.
It seems like you heard the problem of hard solipsism and went crazy with it, trying to apply it haphazardly everywhere that popped into your mind without thinking through if that even is rationally possible.
Yes. Reality “beyond” (all possible) experience is the dehydrated water of metaphysicians. If this sounds wild to you, then perhaps it’s because you think of experience as a brain-created ghost.
I’ll grant that a naive / pre-critical understanding of time gets in the way of understanding a non-ghost-story approach.
My position was like yours once.
Dude, I’ve read the positivists. They told me. I am not saying that every positivist was a phenomenalist, but many of them were. See Schlick’s essay on positivism versus realism. Read Ayer’s appropriation of J. S. Mill in LTL. You might even want to read the “radical idealist” Einstein in the essay Physics and Reality. Einstein in that paper is very close to Mach. You might also look in Schrödinger’s My View of the World. Or Honderich’s “actualism.” Or James’ radical empiricism. I could name more influences. Should I bother ? Are you going to cling to the ghost story as “obvious” ?
I find it amusing — and yet I understand the confusion — that you take a rejection of the ghost story as idealism.
—Consciousness ( mind ) does not exist.
—So you are saying all is mind ???
'But experience MUST be inside-stuff !!!" —because of a pre-critical vague notion of “the past.”
And the…“sin”…of anthropocentrism is just the kind of thing that a status-seeking ape would worry about.
Calling “it” a process looks to me like hiding from the issue. Let’s not pretend that the ghost story isn’t motivated by “animal perspective.” I reject qualia, but I know why people are tempted to postulate such “inside” things.
The mystified crude take on the scientific image is a kind of disavowed mathemagical platonism that “falls into the map.”
The qualities of objects that are not addressed by a particular pragmatic map are declared “unreal” or “epiphenomenal.” So the quality of empirical objects is scraped off and stuffed inside the “ghost stuff” of a subject.
Basically the world is theologically bifurcated, except the theology is not Christian. Still, the central theme of “sacred Truth” remains intact. “Truth” beyond experience, utility, perspective. Another version of God, another object for piety, another flight from embodied life as a dying animal. We even get a chance to overcome the “sin” of anthropocentrism. We can yet again abase ourselves to be exalted, suffer “disenchantment” for the empty but fetishized phrase “Objective Truth.”
I always thought it was an interesting speculation to consider if the notion of an objective reality could arise in a world where no God was ever posited. Or alternately, is the positing of a god inevitable because of our instinct toward thinking about the world in terms of an objective reality.
There is no way you believe a single word of this. You stumbled on this fringe Radical Empiricism/Phenomenalism stuff and thought it sounded smart. But fine. Let’s just assume every word of this is real. If everything you said is true then:
How? If reality beyond your personal experience is a “ghost story,” then why aren’t the “others” you claim to share it with ghost stories, too?
If I do not exist outside of your mind, then I am just a hallucination floating in your bubble. So who the hell are you talking to right now, and why?
The idea that things are there when we are not looking is the most natural because supported by the facts that we all see the same things, and that many, if not most things around us don’t change from day to day. The idea of an objective reality is just the idea that the world is not dependent on human perception―that it would exist, does exist and has existed without us.
I think the positing of God/ gods has more to with concerns about death.
I don’t disagree with the notion of realism, but I don’t think this sentence is correct, or at least is only correct according to a very narrow reading. The term “objective” suggests a point of view, not just a metaphysical model. The OP specifically mentions “God’s POV”. That’s what I’m referring to.
If [ your own presupposed dualism ]…
LOL. You don’t understand what I am saying yet. Did you check in with that “fringe thinker” Einstein ?
Yeah, that’s about it. I was born into a tribe of speaking apes who taught me this technique called “reading.” Certain marks go with certain noises. So you can “listen” to dead people who also “listened” to dead people who also…
Then, like an arrogant maniac, I used my own judgement and picked out the stuff that I thought sounded smart. Respectable types — like you I guess — let others tell them what to believe ?
I appreciate the help, since you generously critique your own position here. The ghost story is absurd. There is no bubble.
Again I point out that your “consciousness as process” was indeed…just the usual ghost story.
One coin, two sides sighs. Experience is understood as a bubble of “inside stuff.” And then some Troo External Reality is defined as what is “outside” that bubble. Anti-empirical sci-fi hogwash, but…harmless.
In the last few years, I really noticed the monological tendency in post-Christian philosophy, which looks more and more like an echo of monotheism. The reasonable basis of “objective reality” is perceptual reality. But philosophers inflate the sign “objective” to signify — in their own wild and unworldly discourse — something grand and obscure and metaphysical.
Before long we get the…sophisticated…notion that experience is “inside stuff.” That objects “don’t really” have value or sensory quality. Joe’s wife is…“really” bleeps and bloops in God’s computer. So Joe’s-wife-for-Joe is inside-Joe-stuff, etc. Basically a sci-fi conspiracy theory, the bongwater sutra…
FWIW, I would even insist that we ferociously pre-theoretically believe in the function of things not currently perceptually present.
This belief is not merely verbal. I walk out of my front door to get to my car that I can’t see yet, expecting it to be there. Then I walk to that car so that I can get to my workplace that I don’t currently percieve. I accept US dollars as payment for my work because I expect the grocery story — also not perceptually present most of the time— to give me food in exchange for those dollars.
For humans it seems that empirical objects exist primarily as perceptually absent means in the umvelt as primarily a “temporal depth.” Of course the umvelt — the pragmatic-empirical world — is spatial too, but this is already appreciated. “Real” time — empirical lived time — is “occluded” by a spatialized-numerical time. People forget to ask why we put up clocks in the first place. What are clocks… for ?
No problems. We can make mistakes at times. But through focused and honest discussions on the subjects, we all learn together on the world, life and mind in the end.
I suppose that is the main point of engaging in philosophical discussions and philosophizing.
I highly salute to your honesty and integrity on the discussion which symbolises the philosophical spirit.
This touches on an important point – what there is vs. what we can know about it. I’m 100% percent sure there’s a world that is not dependent on human perception; I have no such certainty about the degree to which my knowledge of it reflects how that world is when not perceived by me or, more relevantly, by us.
While I prefer this model, I can’t imagine being 100% certain of any metaphysical model. I’m not even sure that the notion of being 100% certain in a metaphysical model is coherent to me. I think I need to, at least provisionally, adopt a metaphysical model in order to consider my certainty in any proposition.
I get that. I almost wrote “99.99%”. Yes, certainty is itself part of a model. But theory aside, I can’t imagine anything that could disconfirm my belief in an external world, so that’s really all I mean.
“Theory aside” is a strange thing to say when discussing metaphysics. I guess I’m thinking about the difference between facts and metaphysical models. I’m not so sure that thoroughly defensible logically coherent metaphysical models are as useful as we often treat them. Not to say they have no utility, just not so much as you’d imagine. Facts, on the other hand, are immensely useful. Does it matter if my coffee machine is “external”, so long as there is coffee made this morning?
Completely agree.
‘Trust in Allah, but tether your camel first’ ~ Arab proverb.