God's POV & Objective Reality

Just a form of words whose intended meaning I expressed and explained immediately before the text you quoted. The soft and hard were explained clearly there to be either unbiased or conformance with that which actually is.

Sorry for any confusion.

I’m not sure if this is a joke?

We all know what objectivity is, or at least, the commonly-accepted meaning of objectivity in a philosophical context. If I have misunderstood it so badly, will you do me the favour of explaining where I’ve gone wrong?

I might put it this way : our judgment of bias is always..biased.

We might disagree about whether a referee for some sport is fair.

As you may already see by now, I currently try to evade dualism by allowing subjectivity to go “all the way down.”

I just don’t assume a reliable ( omniscient ) narrator. We each have the same world differently, in terms of our own sense of what words mean and so on. But my sense of the world and yours are compatible enough for conversation to proceed. I can grant that you are in contact with reality without really understanding what reality is ---- for you.

I can’t help of course but to live out my own life in terms of what I understand and believe. I may try to learn from others and continually enrich my own perspective. I read “the great philosophers” and expose my beliefs to criticism. I hope to become… less stupid and rigid and blind. But to be me is to always be “blind,” merely by understanding the world in one way and not in millions of other ways.

So for me there is not a “true” reality that is hidden “behind” experience-in-general. Rather all experience is “finite” or “partial.” There is only reality but only ever partially, only one glimpse or aspect at a time.

Reality “happens over time and a plurality of subjects.” So the for-me-here-now is always incomplete, never the whole story, yet an absolutely genuine and real piece of the story. The whole story is ongoing and engulfs all of us like the ocean engulfs drops of rain.

1 Like

Objectivity, hard, soft, or otherwise, does not “appear” to me, you, or any other human. So we have nothing to “judge”.

Ah, so all of this concerns reality. Reality as it appears to humans and human senses. Objectivity is irrelevant. It’s just an adjective of confusion that you have added. I wonder why? :thinking:

No it wasn’t. It was just my judgement on your statement. I judge it as subjective opinion lacking objectivity. But it could be my subjectivity from your point of view.

I judge your point as objective. I also made the point previously. Objectivity could be subjectivity. Subjectivity could be objectivity. They have different meanings and definitions depending on the situations and objects being perceived and judged. Also we have different personal criteria for judging too.

1 Like

How? How do you judge such a thing? What equipment (or whatever) do you have that I do not, that enables you to reach this conclusion? How do you judge the veracity or usefulness of your own judgement, here?

Now I’m lost. I was following this rabbit in a waistcoat, with a watch. One minute he was concerned with being late, and now… I’m lost.

I think I made point on that too previously. Judgement is based on psychological state or reasoning process of each individual. It doesn’t need equipment or whatever to make judgement.

For verifying a judgement was true or false, we can use logical proofs if needed. And yes, judgement can be true or false.

If judgement of perception is too difficult to understand, then we can think of objectivity and subjectivity as a point of view.

I see your ideas, and judge it as your subjectivity. From your point of view, you see it, and claim as objectivity. Sometimes we have the same point of view, and sometimes we don’t.

There is nothing unclear here, and no reason to be lost.

I agree that some of Harman’s approach is not like Heidegger at all but just wild Harman stuff. I’m not down with speculative realism, generally speaking. The “world-for-no-one” is dehydrated water.

But I like Wittgenstein’s “pure realism” with a strong dose of Heidegger on the issue of equipment. I like “materialism” that isn’t physicalism. The world pushes back on us. Objects are no less “real” than subjects. The object as temporal synthesis is manifest and then non-manifest. Even when manifest the manifestation is perspectival and partial.

The tool vanishes into its function. The telescope “is” the moon. But this is something we experience, something we live, mostly without noticing it.

Harman ignores that we have to notice that we have not been noticing. I can realize that I have been “blindly” trusting the road to catch my feet. I have “blindly” expected car to start. I “blindly” expect that stepping on the brake pedal will stop the car.

But Harman envisions objects interacting with one another, “outside” of a “consciousness” that he must therefore understand dualistically. Mill already saw that we trust objects to function when we are not perceiving them. So Harman arguably “slides back” from the phenomenalism of Mill. I read Heidegger as a far later and more advanced ( ontological ) phenomenalist.

I don’t think it’s as simple as “nazi stuff ruined him.” Nor do I speak against the later stuff. I have read some of it. I value some of it. But I choose the emphasize the early stuff. This is like betting on a horse. I am writing in English for readers of English. Heidegger is a big influence on my own work, I speak for myself and celebrate influences like Mach, etc. The style should fit the content.

I don’t buy your last claim there. If we go down that road, then Husserl was a nazi, because Heidegger’s earlier work builds on Husserl. I guess the safest thing to do is the discuss the content of the early work…

This is very close to my own approach. I could use “true” like that. Protagoras seems to have been heard that way. Each person’s experience is truth. Truth as disclosure is always partial and relative, but also always a genuine disclosure of “pure reality.”

I might say that everything is experienced in the mode of the experiencer. This is basically what I mean when I say that experience is reality-from-POV and not inside-stuff.

The-world-for-God is more reasonable than the-world-for-one. I take it as expressing an ideal. The “undistorted” object is precisely the-object-for-God, where God is the “ideal” perceiver or knower.

But this is a monological. The “ideal knowing” is singular. The undistorted object is “one.” So an anti-perspectivism is baked in.

I’m not even against this monological approach. I just want it seen and acknowledged, so that a case can be made for it. I suspect dualism is largely grounded in the tacit vague notion of the “true” object singular. The object is “Actually” Just Like This. But this “Actually” is just the monological prejudice. I agree with Gadamer that prejudice is not always bad. Indeed, we are helpless without prejudice. So it’s a matter of foregrounding our prejudices in order to be able to subject them to criticism. They might survive this criticism.

I find some theological thinkers more coherent than opposed scientistic thinkers, precisely because they see the problem and explicitly posit a God to solve this problem, etc. I’m not even an anti-theist. I am more of a heretic who likes Job than a doctrinaire atheist.

Perhaps we have already moved on from this, but I will make a brief case. For Mach — to put it crudely — we have a the from-a-point-of-view phenomenal field. The entities in this field are “neutral elements” because we name and understand them flexibly according to what we are trying to do.

My perception of a chair is part of the empirical being of the chair. It is not an “inside icon” that is other than the chair. But I usually call an “element” a “perception” when I am trying to make sense of a perceiver and not the chair. The same element is a piece of the chair and a piece of a “stream of experience,” depending on what I am trying to do. There is no “chair in itself” or mysterious “external physical chair.” But there is also no “inside sphere.”

There is just the “phenomenal field,” which we might call “world face.” But the world only faces a “witness” when we are doing psychology. The witness is another pragmatic posit.

We also get a very informal nod to synthesis.

Colours, sounds, temperatures, pressures, spaces, times, and so forth, are connected with one another in manifold ways; and with them are associated dispositions of mind, feelings, and volitions. Out of this fabric, that which is relatively more fixed and permanent stands prominently forth, engraves itself on the memory, and expresses itself in language. Relatively greater permanency is exhibited, first, by certain complexes of colours, sounds, pressures, and so forth, functionally connected in time and space, which therefore receive special names, and are called bodies. Absolutely permanent such complexes are not.

My table is now brightly, now dimly lighted. Its temperature varies. It may receive an ink stain. One of its legs may be broken. It may be repaired, polished, and replaced part by part. But, for me, it remains the table at which I daily write.

My friend may put on a different coat. His countenance may assume a serious or a cheerful expression. His complexion, under the effects of light or emotion, may change. His shape may be altered by motion, or be definitely changed. Yet the number of the permanent features presented, compared with the number of the gradual alterations, is always so great, that the latter may be overlooked. It is the same friend with whom I take my daily walk.

My coat may receive a stain, a tear. My very manner of expressing this shows that we are concerned here with a sum-total of permanency, to which the new element is added and from which that which is lacking is subsequently taken away.

Here is Mach on the ego:

The apparent permanency of the ego consists chiefly in the single fact of its continuity, in the slowness of its changes. The many thoughts and plans of yesterday that are continued today, and of which our environment in waking hours incessantly reminds us (whence in dreams the ego can be very indistinct, doubled, or entirely wanting), and the little habits that are unconsciously and involuntarily kept up for long periods of time, constitute the groundwork of the ego. There can hardly be greater differences in the egos of different people, than occur in the course of years in one person. When I recall today my early youth, I should take the boy that I then was, with the exception of a few individual features, for a different person, were it not for the existence of the chain of memories. Many an article that I myself penned twenty years ago impresses me now as something quite foreign to myself.

We also get the shift between object-as-a-whole and its analysis.

Thing, body, matter, are nothing apart from the combinations of the elements, - the colours, sounds, and so forth - nothing apart from their so-called attributes. That protean pseudo-philosophical problem of the single thing with its many attributes, arises wholly from a misinterpretation of the fact, that summary comprehension and precise analysis, although both are provisionally justifiable and for many purposes profitable, cannot be carried on simultaneously.

A last piece toward “nonduality”…

A common and popular way of thinking and speaking is to contrast " appearance " with " reality." A pencil held in front of us in the air is seen by us as straight; dip it into the water, and we see it crooked. In the latter case we say that the pencil appears crooked, but is in reality straight. But what justifies us in declaring one fact rather than another to be the reality, and degrading the other to the level of appearance ? In both cases we have to do with facts which present us with different combinations of the elements, combinations which in the two cases are differently conditioned. Precisely because of its environment the pencil dipped in water is optically crooked; but it is tactually and metrically straight. An image in a concave or flat mirror is only visible, whereas under other and ordinary circumstances a tangible body as well corresponds to the visible image. A bright surface is brighter beside a dark surface than beside one brighter than itself. To be sure, our expectation is deceived when, not paying sufficient attention to the conditions, and substituting for one another different cases of the combination, we fall into the natural error of expecting what we are accustomed to, although the case may be an unusual one. The facts are not to blame for that. In these cases, to speak of " appearance " may have a practical meaning, but cannot have a scientific meaning. Similarly, the question which is often asked, whether the world is real or whether we merely dream it, is devoid of all scientific meaning. Even the wildest dream is a fact as much as any other. If our dreams were more regular, more connected, more stable, they would also have more practical importance for us. In our waking hours the relations of the elements to one another are immensely amplified in comparison with what they were in our dreams. We recognise the dream for what it is. When the process is reversed, the field of psychic vision is narrowed; the contrast is almost entirely lacking. Where there is no contrast, the distinction between dream and waking, between appearance and reality, is quite otiose and worthless.

The popular notion of an antithesis between appearance and reality has exercised a very powerful influence on scientific and philosophical thought. We see this, for example, in Plato’s pregnant and poetical fiction of the Cave, in which, with our backs turned towards the fire, we observe merely the shadows of what passes (Republic, vii. 1). But this conception was not thought out to its final consequences, with the result that it has had an unfortunate influence on our ideas about the universe. The universe, of which nevertheless we are a part, became completely separated from us, and was removed an infinite distance away.

From the Rovelli wiki:

Relational quantum mechanics (RQM) is an interpretation of quantum mechanics which treats the state of a quantum system as being relational, that is, the state is the relation between the observer and the system. This interpretation was first delineated by Carlo Rovelli in a 1994 preprint,[1] and has since been expanded upon by a number of theorists. It is inspired by the key idea behind special relativity, that the details of an observation depend on the reference frame of the observer

The essential idea behind RQM is that different observers may give different accurate accounts of the same system. For example, to one observer, a system is in a single, “collapsed” eigenstate. To a second observer, the same system is in a superposition of two or more states and the first observer is in a correlated superposition of two or more states. RQM argues that this is a complete picture of the world because the notion of “state” is always relative to some observer. There is no privileged, “real” account.

RQM is close to what I mean by “phenomenalism,” as something like a specialized analogy.

the state is the relation between the observer and the system.

This “state” is then an analogy for a “moment” of an object. For instance, a “perception” is such a “moment.”

To put it very roughly, the object “is” all “perceptions” of that object. But “perception” is a misleading term here, because it is is associated with a dualist postulation of consciousness as “ghost in the pineal gland” stuff. “Consciousness does not exist” — is not postulated. Only the objects of the world are postulated, but they exist “relationally.” To put very crudely, there are only “states” ( moments ) are just as much subject as object.

This is equivalent to the “neutrality” of Mach’s elements. This is not the postulation of a neutral fundamental stuff. The category of this or that entity is “real enough” but a matter of perspective.

Subjects as “streams of experience” are “made of” or “constituted by” pieces or moments of objects. The same “object pieces” constitute objects and subjects at the same time. We have different purpose-relative ways of gluing together the same qualitative moments.

We might want to try to build objects out of a “subject pieces.” In some sense this is equivalent, but it loses the intensely experienced transcendence of objects. It feeds in to the old “ghost story” of consciousness-stuff in “pineal glands.”

The essential idea behind RQM is that different observers may give different accurate accounts of the same system.

This is an especially radical piece of RQM. I am just learning about it, largely from @Andy, but this idea violates the “God’s Eye View” that perhaps most people associate with physics.

This means that there is no “true” object or “true” state of the object. The object is unified as a speakable “common” or “public” — as a temporal intersubjective synthesis — but it has no “central” or “true” moment or “face.” The object has no “solid core.”

What he says about 40 minutes in is especially relevant.

1 Like

To put it another way : if I had access somehow to the stream of life’s experience, would I learn about you or the objects in your life ?

I would learn about objects-for-you. Because I am still me as I do this, I would experience objects-for-you-for-me.

A cruder “non-objective approach” might use phrases like true-for-you and true-for-me. This is structurally coherent, but the use of “true” in this way clashes with the dominant “objective-monological” tendency.

If the goal is merely to foreground the alternative and not convince or convert, then we especially want to avoid terms that active the prejudice being excavated. Again I note that “prejudice” is a neutral term. It is a fore-having or pre-judging of the situation that we enact unconsciously, just by hearing a particular word to have this significance rather than that one.

I am also serious about prioritizing foregrounding or converting or persuading. I’d even enjoy someone else on the forum to explicitly embraced the God’s Eye approach and therefore didn’t handwave about its obviousness but made a case for it. This would require seeing as a presupposition and then consciously investigating it and finally endorsing it.

Has no “own being” (svabhava). His chess example is instructive – I associate this with the concept in physics of symmetry breaking – e.g. the laws of physics admit of endless kinds of chemistry, but once that symmetry breaks only one kind of chemistry has been selected and all the other possibilities become counterfactuals. Same when we move from chemistry to biology. So, as he says, when his bicycle breaks he doesn’t go looking for a quantum mechanic. Wrong level of description.

1 Like

The bicycle part was great. The bicycle is as “real” as anything else. Signs like “pedal” and “brake” and “spoke” are no more and no less fundamental than “charge” and “mass.” Some of his comments remind me of Heidegger and Harman. We “push and pull” and depend on objects. His bicycle repair guy has the “right” level of description because Rovelli wants to ride that bike, and the mechanic can help him realize that desired future.

Elsewhere he points out that physics is “overrated.” I think he means metaphysically overrate, because of course he loves physics.

Yes. that is a great term. Is that Sanskrit ? My brief investigate suggests that it’s an especially great language.

No own-being as in no intact-as-isolated gunk. “No finite entity has genuine being.” Chess is indeed a great example. The pawn is defined in terms of the queen ( it can become a queen.) The queen is powerful relative to less mobile pieces. The pieces might be made of wood or glass. Any shapes we can agree on will do. We enact Chess. Or Chess is one of the things that enacts us.

1 Like

My mistake. I was lost trying to understand what your words had to do with Objectivity (etc). Now I see I was really lost, as you are using these words to mean something different. I got confused.

1 Like

I do. Reality presents itself to us in specific ways. Our senses developed to perceive reality in the ways it presents itself to us. No, we don’t perceive reality in all the ways it presents itself. But the ways in which we perceive it are incomplete, not inaccurate.

It may have been assumed for millennia that, say, a rock can be broken into smaller and smaller pieces forever, and the smaller pieces would always be rock. Or maybe some believed they would eventually reach an indivisible, microscopic pieces of rock.

Well, now we know better. But the fact that the ultimate building block of a rock is not rock does not mean a rock is not a rock. It means this is what rock is made of.

If there are entities with senses unlike ours, so that they perceive reality in ways it presents itself that we know nothing about, a rock is still a rock. Outside of comic books, we can’t pass through rock, regardless of which way, and how many ways, we perceive what it is presenting.

1 Like

I believe personally that objective reality, in my opinion, is the physical world around you. That you cannot disprove the reality of some things, like a leaf, or a tree, or a body of water. For example, if you walk away from a tree and look back the tree is still there, it still exists in objective reality.

Objective reality is a reality that is true and has been true our whole existence, and a reality that you can physically feel, sense, hear, smell and taste.

1 Like

You’re not accounting here for the more metaphysical aspects of the discussion, then? That we could possibly be (for instance) brains-in-vats, even though we might/would/could not realise it?

We are all entitled to our beliefs. :+1: But the usually-understood meaning, in philosophical contexts, of “objective reality” is something like ‘that which actually is, irrespective of our ideas, beliefs, etc.’