When did we start thinking in first person?

I’m with you. We don’t prove any of this stuff. Rather the framework of “people-proving-stuff-to-one-another” is finally foregrounded. This is what I mean by “the forum.” Our flesh in the world “enacts” the “fiction” of responsible time-binding selfhood. Robert Brandom’s language is dry, but the gist is radical.

We “are”…deep deep prejudice, sign-flinging-flesh-pattern “beneath” what we can dredge up. Dreyfus is good on this in Being-in-the-world. Braver’s Groundless Grounds is also good. Braver also discusses Hume. I think we can read Hume “problem of induction” in a very animal way, that leads us to what I would call a self-honesty about the basis of our cognition, which is not verbal-Euclidean. “Proof with words” is a very high level super-structure.

Right. So what the hell is this “I” ? The “being” of the subject is often taken for granted. Clearly language is crucial here. But what is language ? “Internal pure thought stuff” ? But why “internal” ? Is the “I” a…metaphysical container ? Is this an empirical discovery, our a by-now-compulsive enacted metaphor ?

The self is mostly a “bot,” as you hint. I do what “one” does, say what “one” says in a thousand little automatic routines. This is part of my rejection of dualism. If we loosen up our prejudices about the “I” and our related prejudices about language, then it’s easier to notice the way the world is non-theoretically lived with other people.

Reminds me of Nietzsche’s celebration of determinism in Twilight. Basically the whole drama of sin is modified. The world becomes a unified music, a god with ten millions faces that smooch and eat one another. Consciousness is no longer “internal ghost stuff” but the raw presence of this mighty spectacle, albeit more or less explicitly from the pOV of a particular animal’s body.

1 Like

Not apropos of Julian Jaynes in particular, but relevant to the question posed in the title and may be of interest.

Richard Sorabji — Self: Ancient and Modern Insights about Individuality, Life, And Death

Discusses personal identity; memory; the importance of seeing one’s life as a whole; the relation between self, intellect, will, and agency; self-awareness; the stream of consciousness; embodiment; death and survival. Rejects the view that the self is an illusion, and develops original conception of the self as essential to our ownership of our experience and our apprehension of the world.

Philip Cary — Augustine’s Invention of the Inner Self: The Legacy of a Christian Platonist

Augustine invents the inner self in order to solve a particular conceptual problem. Augustine is attracted to the Neoplatonist inward turn, which located God within the soul, yet remains loyal to the orthodox Catholic teaching that the soul is not divine. He combines the two emphases by urging us to enter the inner world of the self before gazing at the divine Light above the human mind.

It’s also worth noting that Augustine articulated a version of Descartes’ famous cogito ergo sum millenia before Descartes did, saying '“Yet who ever doubts that he himself lives… even if he doubts, he lives… he knows that he does not know…”

1 Like

Here’s an anthropological article about how those “hearing voices” experience those voices in different cultures.

https://news.stanford.edu/stories/2014/07/voices-culture-luhrmann-071614?utm_source=chatgpt.com

Apparently, there’s something about our rationalist world view that leads the voices to be harsher and more troublesome than they are in other cultures.

Obviously, we always fail to recognize our own prejudices (if we recognized them we would alter them), however quick we are to notice those of others.

2 Likes

In my view, becoming aware of one’s own prejudices does not necessarily make one’s position any more advantageous. For one thing, prejudice is a fundamental condition for our understanding of anything; prior knowledge shapes how we encounter the new, and it is only through prejudice that we gain the ability to evaluate things—after all, none of us possesses a “God’s-eye view,” a perspective on the world from the vantage point of “pure being.” The very categories we use to think are, in themselves, prejudices.

Furthermore, recognizing one’s prejudices—and even having the capacity to revise them—does not grant one the ability to step “beyond” them. Even when you understand your own prejudices, you still cannot claim to have a “pure” or untainted perspective. And, most importantly, once you have revised them, the question arises: what should you replace them with?

Thus, holding prejudices—such as the belief in the existence of one’s own “self,” or the conviction that gods are telling one how to act—constitutes a conscious orientation, which in turn leads to specific, corresponding consequences.

Consider the title of the article you cited: “Stanford anthropologist claims that hallucinatory ‘voices’ are shaped by local culture.” There is no mention here of the fact that the anthropologist’s own conception of her “self” is likewise shaped by her own local culture.

And now, a question: why is a mode of existence centered on a defined “self” inherently preferable to a mode of existence centered on the “voices of the gods”?

1 Like

Here is another interesting detail.

In my experience, I have encountered very few people who truly and fully embrace the autonomy of their own “self.” It is incredibly difficult to look inward and acknowledge that one is the sole author of everything one thinks or does.

And that’s not even considering others—I’m not even sure I’m capable of living that way myself. It is often far easier to attribute the cause of one’s troubles to external circumstances, sheer chance, or the malicious intent of others.

Take academic literature, for example. An author might write, “Given A, it follows that B.” They present it as if B follows from A of its own accord—as if the author’s own experience, biases, and perspective played no part whatsoever. To state in an essay, “This is the case because I believe it to be so, based on the narratives I have adopted,” would be considered almost the gravest sin a scholar could commit. Instead, one is expected to distance oneself as much as possible from the authorship of one’s own conclusions; otherwise, critics will simply dismiss your ideas as things you “just made up.”

“Made up?” Well, damn it—yes, I did make it up. Everything I say—I made it up. I am the author of it.

To admit that—that is incredibly difficult.

The irony is that while modern philosophers might criticize ancient people for hearing the “voices of the gods” in their heads, they themselves effectively muffle the voices of Heidegger, Kant, or Aristotle within their own minds—only to let those very same figures become the only voices heard when it comes time to justify their own positions. The voice of personal authorship is recast as the “voice of objective, unbiased reasoning.”

Consider the paradox: we solemnly proclaim ourselves the authors of our own actions, yet simultaneously hide that authorship behind a veil of “independent sources.”

Perhaps the hypothesis that humans 3,000 years ago possessed a “bicameral mind” is a bit of a stretch. I have no doubt about that. But consider how many cameras we ourselves possess. Is it just one—the one we might call the “unbiased perspective”? Or is there another—one where there is only my own “self,” and nothing else?

This topic has really captured my interest; for some reason, it had previously escaped my notice. Perhaps everything has its own proper time. In any case, it truly gives one pause for thought.

2 Likes

I’m with you. At least when it comes to the generic critic, which is something like the narcissistic complacent tendency in all of us. The smart way is to put out your own ideaas the “true meaning” of this or that name with “mana.” Kojeve used Hegel, Plato used Socrates, etc. On the other hand, nobody has ever had their own idea. Yes, there can be a sufficient squirt of originality so that progress is made, but we are primarily “communal subject goo.” An especially lucky poet/engineer adds a brick to the wall that people in a particular discourse bother to remember and discuss.

So I agree with your general critique, but my friend you are currently paraphrasing Heidegger, who is perhaps the last person to invoke “unbiased” reasoning. “Freedom of standpoint = ruin of a subject.” In other words, subjectivity (personality) is bias. A person without prejudices is like a computer without an OS — basically nothing. The “view from nowhere” is too absurd to be plausible except as a mask for “the view from God.”

To someone else you said:

This is precisely Heidegger/Gadamer stuff. “Prejudice” is a neutral concept. “Historical reason” can become conscious of itself as such. Rorty discusses this, confessing the inescapability of an ethnocentrism that cannot and need not justify itself in some “pure theological reason.”

So this:

The voice of personal authorship is recast as the “voice of objective, unbiased reasoning.”

does not apply to recent “continental” philosophy. On the other hand, it does apply to a still dominant “pre-pomo” self-concept. So I get it. I’m just saying that not all philosophy is so allergic to taking credit for personal creative breakthrough. Indeed, on the “continental” side there’s even a noisy self-conscious quest for the next revolution that can be signed. This “pomo” philosophy suffers the anxiety of influence (Harold Bloom.) The fear is not of insufficient objectivity but insufficient genuine subjectivity. What we have in this case is institutionalized revolution, but the institution has the memory of an elephant. Your critics ( peers in this regime ) will tell you that “it’s already been said.” They are usually right.

I suggest that we all live the doublethink discussed in 1984. We understand one another as meat in the causal nexus and at the same time perform responsible selfhood. To be “free” is to be subject to praise and blame. We like people who take responsibility for their actions, who act coherently, who bind time in a way that we can make sense of. We like self-policing people. We like the body in the prison of the soul. And I’m good with that. But our other eye sees a machine that can be predicted. Or rather we enact that expectation. Here’s that Hume quote again.

A prisoner who has neither money nor interest, discovers the impossibility of his escape, as well when he considers the obstinacy of the gaoler, as the walls and bars with which he is surrounded; and, in all attempts for his freedom, chooses rather to work upon the stone and iron of the one, than upon the inflexible nature of the other. The same prisoner, when conducted to the scaffold, foresees his death as certainly from the constancy and fidelity of his guards, as from the operation of the axe or wheel. His mind runs along a certain train of ideas: The refusal of the soldiers to consent to his escape; the action of the executioner; the separation of the head and body; bleeding, convulsive motions, and death. Here is a connected chain of natural causes and voluntary actions; but the mind feels no difference between them in passing from one link to another: Nor is less certain of the future event than if it were connected with the objects present to the memory or senses, by a train of causes, cemented together by what we are pleased to call a physical necessity.

To me this is maybe the great topic. It connects to all the great issues.

1 Like

This passage reminds me of Jung’s idea of the shadow.

The striking difference was that while many of the African and Indian subjects registered predominantly positive experiences with their voices, not one American did. Rather, the U.S. subjects were more likely to report experiences as violent and hateful – and evidence of a sick condition.

The Americans experienced voices as bombardment and as symptoms of a brain disease caused by genes or trauma.

One participant described the voices as “like torturing people, to take their eye out with a fork, or cut someone’s head and drink their blood, really nasty stuff.” Other Americans (five of them) even spoke of their voices as a call to battle or war – “‘the warfare of everyone just yelling.’”

Exactly. The prejudices worth talking about here are the one’s we don’t know we have. I agree with Gadamer that knowledge of others also involves a further knowledge of the self. Basically we have to clarify the object ( the other ) by removing our hitherto unconscious prejudices from the object and claiming them instead as…ourselves. So “projection” is a fundamental phenomenon.

After I posted this and reread it, I noticed the seemingly inconsistencies here. But the logic of the entire post is built around discovering these inconsistencies.

I’m a master at consolidating various positions. On the one hand, my thoughts arise from premises I’ve read, plus some of my own (including my mood). On the other hand, I want to be the sole author. On the third hand, I’m afraid of authorship, because it comes with responsibility.

All of this is in constant flux.

I think the ancients had something similar, but with different emphases. And it’s precisely these emphases that define our era.

I say something, and it seems new to me. Five minutes later, it all seems ancient; after a response to my words, it turns out that all this has already been said and forgotten a couple of thousand years ago.

It’s surprising, but reading someone like Hume or Kant with the baggage that modern philosophers have given us is not the same as reading them for the first time. I want to say, “Well, there you have it—Kant has it all.”

Details, nuances, new distinctions expressed by new linguistic signs—all of this, it seems, is an endless process.

2 Likes

I relate to all of this. I spend lots of time thinking about the problem of writing. The problem of how to say what I want to say. I get excited by the sense that I can say the ancient stuff in a slightly new way. I settle for that tiny piece of originality. I will settle for one little signed brick. But I remain anonymous, because I don’t…trust people. Or maybe I don’t trust myself. Or I don’t know exactly how I want to play it yet. More brash ? More cautious ? As you say, it comes with responsibility. The tragic component in my view is not something I want to force on people. It’s not for everyone, but on the internet you sort of have to put it in ears where it does not belong. Yet I like to think that my primary goal is sharing in understanding the deep stuff with others. So we can all be anonymous temple artists, egging one another on toward a slightly better or at least fresh paraphrase.

I’m with you on this. But I might project “having it all” on the fragments of Heraclitus. The shape of Kant’s basic project, though, is it. He just wasn’t sufficiently realistic about time. So Hegel and Heidegger push his general project deeper into lived historical reality. Braver’s A Thing of This World is about this evolutionary journey from Kant to Derrida, etc.

I’m with you on “endless process.” If we leave behind the prejudice that we are matching a “fixed external reality” with some arrangement of a “fixed eternal set of essences,” then we move into a sense of finitude, which means infinity or the abandonment of the end of inquiry of as a goal. This “end of inquiry” as goal is maybe even a death wish. Existence “is” mortal incarnate inquiry. The end of inquiry for the monological dream is that all personality converges on the same ideal personality, so there’s nothing to talk about and really no one left to talk to anyway. Not that people really want this, but it is implied by the tacit assumption of the One Right Belief that Mirrors Reality.

2 Likes

Hence the demand of philosophical spirituality to transcend the personal. Science too grew out of that demand but became restricted in scope to the quantitative and the measurable.

2 Likes

I agree. I think the situation here is roughly this: what we read in Kant, Aristotle, or Hume serves as a starting point for a chain of further reasoning. We, in turn, take these ideas up—developing them, enriching them, and discovering new connections.

In this sense, I would argue that our own “authorship” lies not so much in adding a single brick to the wall, but rather in forging new connections between the bricks already there. It is precisely these connections that we strive to generate, and the very possibility of creating them is what inspires us to pursue further inquiry.


I also cannot help but ask you the following:

Existentialism seems to have become such an organic, integral part of modern life that we no longer view it as a mere “superstructure,” but rather as the very substance of life itself.

In philosophy, this is well-understood; in everyday life, the call to “find oneself” is ubiquitous—it’s everywhere—and each of us dreams of becoming an author, at the very least, of our own life.

The initial premise of our discussion prompted me to wonder: what if we were to imagine a person whose fundamental “configuration” was, in fact, the “two-chambered” structure we’ve been describing? If such a person were to appear right here among us, how might their life unfold?

In other words, is it strictly necessary for one’s fundamental existential premise to be the “doctrine” of the “Self” as the author of one’s own project?

What are your thoughts on this?

2 Likes

Yes, it was, and well-thought.

1 Like

I’d say that science itself is still solid in that regard. It’s only the metaphysical “reading” of science —typically physics ---- as the final and true ontology that is problematic.

Then I’d say the goal transcend the petty personal. We try to meet others in high ways of thinking and feeling. We need not assume only one high place to meet others. Perhaps every great relationship is unique.

To remain a human being is to be biased. To think and feel and live in a some “high” way is exclusive in its specificity. “Bias” or “prejudice” is a neutral term for me. It’s a way of approaching the future, including our future with others.

1 Like

Yes, I like your “connection forging” approach. The brick metaphor is a little clunky.I hope to connect Mach and Hobbes and Heidegger and to remind people of the forgotten Feuerbach.

I am doing something like what Braver did in his book.

I suppose the good thing about the otherwise clunky brick metaphor is that it emphasizes the relative smallness of most contributions.

It’s a big part of the American ideology. Be an influencer. Be famous for being you. Or start your own business. You yourself are the brand. You are a self-marketing product, and yet also an idol to be envied, if your product sells well.

I suppose everyone wants to be happy, to have some say in their life. But does everyone want to be an author in the stronger sense of the word, a conspicuously original personality ? Not in my experience. It is a risky project.

Can you explain this use of “two-chambered” ?

Not necessary at all. It’s maybe an ideal that (re-)emerged perhaps with the Romantics. The traditional ideal is conformity with the venerable pattern.

In the case of a philosopher of historicity, we get the weird combination of a sense of mostly not being a self at all and yet the desire for that small piece of novelty to be crystallized and recognized by others.

1 Like

Precisely this:

Perhaps this is a quirk of the translator.

2 Likes

Now I know what you mean. Well they might be put away ! They would count as mad, sick, unfortunate. Unless…they were great poets, sexy rockstars…then wild hipster rocknroll people might respect it, take it as a joke, etc.

There are some famous cases of modern people who hear voices adapting to their situation.

1 Like

Or billionaires with “mental health issues”

1 Like

If you are using hand tools instead of a keyboard the differences is hand tools have the capability of removing a digital, appendage or your take your life. So the two hemispheres and corpus callosum are under different stresses than someone pondering Julian Jaynes’s theory of the bicameral mind over a laptop because when you press the space bar on your computer it doesn’t have the capability of removing your digits and forcing you to go to a different numbering system. From 10 base to 9 base and so on.

The better living conditions, rise of writing and mathematics, and the birth of metaphor, less stresses in everyday life, a rise in top down planning, etc. has changed us. We are just moving out of the dark ages when it comes to understanding brain functions so anything written in the 50’s would have to be taken with a pinch of salt.

1 Like

Here’s the beginning of the suicide note Virginia Woolf wrote to her husband Leaonard:

Dearest, I feel certain that I am going mad again. I feel we can’t go through another of those terrible times. And I shan’t recover this time. I begin to hear voices, and I can’t concentrate. So I am doing what seems the best thing to do. You have given me the greatest possible happiness…

So apparently “hearing voices” was troubling in 1940 even for famous artists.

One of my brothers is schizophrenic. He was untreated for years, because he didn’t want treatment, and the family debated whether he should be forced to get it. He got in more trouble when he was untreated (at one point, he ran afoul of the law and received a one year suspended sentence, which meant if he transgressed within that year he could be sent immediately to prison, where he would have been incapable of faring well.) He is now on anti-psychotic drugs, but he is far from “normal”. None of this would matter to me if he was happy. He isn’t. Like Virginia Woolf. I somehow doubt he would be happy in a different cultural situation, but I don’t know.

By the way, I read the Virginia Woolf wiki page because I am leading a discussion on “To the Lighthouse” for my book club this evening. Any feedback on what questions I should ask would be appreciated. The novel is famed for being a modernistic “stream of consciousness”. But it seems to me that it is more like a stream of unconsciousness – like a dream. One reads it. It’s great. But then one only half remembers what one has read. Like a dream.

2 Likes

My memories and desires are only indistinguishable from my dreams by sleep

Life is creative. If we focused too much on Jaynes’s timelines we miss out on how he addresses creative inspiration, imagination, and the “muse” relate to the evolution of human consciousness.