I’m with you. We don’t prove any of this stuff. Rather the framework of “people-proving-stuff-to-one-another” is finally foregrounded. This is what I mean by “the forum.” Our flesh in the world “enacts” the “fiction” of responsible time-binding selfhood. Robert Brandom’s language is dry, but the gist is radical.
We “are”…deep deep prejudice, sign-flinging-flesh-pattern “beneath” what we can dredge up. Dreyfus is good on this in Being-in-the-world. Braver’s Groundless Grounds is also good. Braver also discusses Hume. I think we can read Hume “problem of induction” in a very animal way, that leads us to what I would call a self-honesty about the basis of our cognition, which is not verbal-Euclidean. “Proof with words” is a very high level super-structure.
Right. So what the hell is this “I” ? The “being” of the subject is often taken for granted. Clearly language is crucial here. But what is language ? “Internal pure thought stuff” ? But why “internal” ? Is the “I” a…metaphysical container ? Is this an empirical discovery, our a by-now-compulsive enacted metaphor ?
The self is mostly a “bot,” as you hint. I do what “one” does, say what “one” says in a thousand little automatic routines. This is part of my rejection of dualism. If we loosen up our prejudices about the “I” and our related prejudices about language, then it’s easier to notice the way the world is non-theoretically lived with other people.
Reminds me of Nietzsche’s celebration of determinism in Twilight. Basically the whole drama of sin is modified. The world becomes a unified music, a god with ten millions faces that smooch and eat one another. Consciousness is no longer “internal ghost stuff” but the raw presence of this mighty spectacle, albeit more or less explicitly from the pOV of a particular animal’s body.