Solipsism - Is the Mind All that Exists?

Nope

Semantic externalism? A mind only would lack the causal history by which it could have acquired its vocabulary and capacity to imagine external environments and things.

Thats a very good question

The point is that we don’t need rhe degree of certainty about the nature of external existence that Descartes claims.

It may be sufficient that we accept that all arguments are fallible and choose a set of assumptions that is capable of generating useful answers and test those against the available evidence

“Let us not pretend to doubt in philosophy what we do not doubt in our hearts”

Charles Sanders Peirce

Yeah, I mean solipsism and radical skepticism aren’t very pragmatic, but they still offer food for thought and are seemingly quite hard to refute/disprove.

1 Like

Right, but we can prove that their claims are meaningless. :smiling_face_with_sunglasses:

1 Like

I don’t really think I would say meaningless, more so pointless.

1 Like

I think Wittgenstein put it most succinctly in Tractatus where the viewer cannot find themselves in a field of view but the recognition leads to accepting the “real” without qualification. You don’t get to cut the cards after that for another round of play.